Friday, June 26, 2026

VA - Visa Versa (A Butterboy Compilation) (4 x CDs)

MEN WHO SOUND LIKE WOMEN & WOMEN WHO SOUD LIKE MEN

VA - Visa Versa (A Butterboy Compilation) (4 x CDs)

There is a moment, rare but unmistakable, when the ear makes a decision before the mind can intervene. A voice enters, unannounced and unqualified, and the listener assigns it a body, a gender, a presence. Visa Versa is built from that fracture, the instant where perception reveals its own fragility.

Across popular music, certain voices have long unsettled expectation. The high, floating falsetto of artists like Frankie Valli or Smokey Robinson once slipped easily across radio waves, often unmoored from any visual context. Heard without introduction, these performances could be read as female, not because they imitate women, but because they inhabit tonal spaces culturally coded as feminine, lightness, delicacy, a certain emotional translucence. In contrast, the work of Phranc or Ferron strips the voice of ornament and gesture, settling into a low, speech-adjacent register that carries the weight and authority listeners often, perhaps unconsciously, assign to male voices.

What emerges is not mimicry, but erasure. The most convincing moments in this compilation do not exaggerate gender traits, they remove them. A flattened vibrato, a narrowed melodic range, a phrasing that leans closer to speaking than singing, these elements displace the usual cues the brain relies on. In tracks by Big Mama Thornton or Tanita Tikaram, the effect is immediate. The voice does not ask to be interpreted; it is simply heard, and misheard, in equal measure.

Visa Versa does not present this as novelty. Instead, it invites a more attentive kind of listening, one that acknowledges how much of what we hear is shaped by expectation rather than sound itself. The compilation moves between poles, male voices that drift into feminine space, female voices that anchor themselves in masculine ground, but the real subject lies between them. It is the instability of the boundary, the ease with which it dissolves, and the quiet revelation that follows.

Sequenced as a whole, the collection becomes less about inversion and more about continuity. Voices echo across tracks, not in identity but in texture, in phrasing, in the subtle ways they refuse categorisation. Visa Versa suggests that gender in music is not a fixed property of the voice, but a perception constructed in real time, by the listener, and just as easily undone.

In that undoing, the compilation finds its purpose. It does not correct the listener, nor does it expose a trick. It simply allows the voice to exist in a space where expectation falters, and where, for a moment, sound is heard before it is understood. (B)

CD1 & CD2 Male Voices Perceived Female

CD3 & Cd4 Female Voices, Perceived Male

==========================================================

OR

===========================================================

Track lists

CD1 M-F1

01 Little Jimmy Scott - Jealous Guy 5:23

02 Frankie Lymon and The Teenagers - Why Do Fools Fall in Love 2:22

03 Smokey Robinson & the Miracles - Ooo Baby Baby 2:47

04 Delfonics - La-La Means I Love You 3:19

05 Stylistics - You Are Everything 2:57

06 Blue Magic - Sideshow 4:06

07 Russell Thompkins, Jr. - Could it Be I'm Falling in Love (Single Edit) 3:58

08 Eddie Holman - Hey There Lonely Girl (Stereo Single Edit) [Jan 14, 1970] 3:12

09 Little Anthony & The Imperials - Going Out of My Head 2:29

10 Pavlov's Dog - She Came Shining 4:19

11 Neil Sedaka - Laughter in The Rain (Stereo Single Version) [November 26, 1974] 2:47

12 Robin Mcnamara - Lay A Little Lovin' on Me 3:04

13 Chris Montez - Call Me 2:38

14 Wayne Newton - Danke Schoen 2:38

15 Curt Boettcher - I Just Want to Be Your Friend 2:19

16 Emitt Rhodes - Come Ride, Come Ride 2:53

17 Nick Gilder - Hot Child in The City 3:08

18 PhD - I Won't Let You Down 4:05

19 Active Child - Hanging On 5:26

20 Stories - Brother Louie 3:51


CD2 M-F2

21 Little Jimmy Scott - Day By Day 4:48

22 Klaus Nomi - The Cold Song 4:04

23 Nick Gilder [UK 1977] - Roxy Roller 2:48

24 Bronski Beat - Smalltown Boy 5:03

25 Rhye - Open 3:37

26 Antony and the Johnsons - Hope There's Someone 4:42

27 Jeff Buckley - Corpus Christi Carol 2:57

28 Aled Jones - Walking in The Air 3:22

29 Philippe Jaroussky & Ensemble Matheus - Vedro con mio diletto (Anastasio) 5:11

30 Sigur Ros - Svefn-G-Englar 8:58

31 M83 - Skin of The Night 6:12

32 Cigarettes After Sex - Apocalypse 4:50

33 Patrick Watson - Height of The Feeling 3:59

34 Delays - Nearer Than Heaven 3:28

35 Murlocs - Empty Nester 3:04

36 Bobb Trimble - Premonitions - The Fantasy 6:04

37 Low - Open Arms 4:02

38 Peter Ivers - In Heaven (Lady in the Radiator Song) 1:38

39 Todd Rundgren - I Saw the Light 3:00

40 Stylistics - Betcha By Golly, Wow 3:18


CD3 F-M1

01 Ferron - I Am Hungry 5:48

02 Phranc - I Enjoy Being A Girl 3:18

03 Tracy Chapman - Give Me One Reason 4:27

04 Nina Simone - Sinnerman 10:19

05 Big Mama Thornton - Hound Dog 2:51

06 Tanita Tikaram - Men and Women 3:08

07 Joan Armatrading - I Wanna Hold You 3:46

08 Aldous Harding - Leathery Whip 4:00

09 Nico - My Funny Valentine 3:24

10 Karen Dalton - Something on Your Mind 3:23

11 Marianne Faithfull - Goin' Back 3:41

12 Annette Peacock - Pony 6:17

13 Alabama Shakes - Sound & Color 3:02

14 Beach House - Walk in the Park 5:22

15 Sophie Hunger - Le vent nous portera 3:46

16 Rough Trade - All Touch 3:32

17 Amanda Lear - Made in France 2:12

18 Millie Jackson - All the Way Lover 5:00

19 Diamanda Galás - Let My People Go 6:05

20 Holy Moses - Angel of Death 3:21


CD4 F-M2

21 Ferron - Ain't Life a Brook 3:29

22 October Project - Ariel 3:11

23 Timi Yuro - The Love of a Boy 2:27

24 Helen Shapiro - Not Responsible 2:38

25 We Five - You Were on My Mind 2:36

26 Toni Childs - Don't Walk Away 4:00

27 Maria Bethânia - Ye-Mele 1:44

28 Amanda Palmer - Leeds United 4:46

29 Toni Braxton - I Don't Want To 4:16

30 Dayna Kurtz - Love Gets in The Way 3:46

31 Shocking Blue - Venus 3:04

32 Beach House - Used to Be 3:58

33 Pj Harvey - This Wicked Tongue 3:46

34 Paybacks - Black Girl 3:17

35 Bernice Johnson Reagon - Been in the Storm So Long 3:54

36 Mary Cutrufello - Candy in The Window 4:05

37 Odetta - Masters of War 6:17

38 Della Reese - Don't You Know 2:33

39 Richard and Linda Thompson - The End of the Rainbow 3:53

40 Babe Ruth - Wells Fargo (Single A-Side) 3:32

=============================================================

=============================================================

Music weaves itself into the fabric of our emotions, dances through the corridors of memory, and whispers to the soul of who we are. Sharing these stories deepens the connection, turning the experience into something timeless and profound.

=============================================================

=============================================================

12 comments:

  1. Nominate: K.D. Lang - The Air That I Breathe (Killer song, killer voice.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Spidey,
      Great nomination, k.d. lang absolutely owns “The Air That I Breathe.” That voice can level a room, and her take brings a richness and control that’s pure class.
      Cheers.

      Delete
  2. Another great compilation, thanks BB. I put added Amanda Palmer to my daily CD 'playlist' the other day and had that moment of the 'wrong' gender sound before I tuned in to who it was. Rush songs often do that to me - when I first heard them I couldn't help comparing the vocals to Pavlovs Dog.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi LeKermitage,
      That moment of the “wrong” gender hitting the ear is such a familiar and delightful jolt. Amanda Palmer can absolutely throw the brain off for a second, and Rush has fooled generations with that high, bright vocal tone. Pavlov’s Dog is a perfect comparison, once you’ve heard David Surkamp, you never forget that timbre.
      Those little slips in expectation are part of what makes Visa Versa fun. Voices don’t always sit where we think they should, and that surprise is half the charm. Thanks for sharing the thought, and glad this one caught your interest.
      Cheers.

      Delete
  3. Hi BB, What a great point of view to see (hear) the music... Thank you for this compilation. Ciao

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Christiaan111,
      I’m really glad the concept spoke to you, looking at music from a different angle often brings out colours and connections we don’t notice at first. This set was a joy to shape, and it’s wonderful to hear it resonated that way for you.
      Cheers.

      Delete
  4. Such a brilliant idea, and I appreciate how much time and effort it takes to put something like this together. What a cool concept. I never would have thought of this and it really is brilliant. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Pol,
      Thank you, that’s really kind. This one was a joy (albeit difficult) to build, and I’m glad the concept clicked for you. Sometimes an idea arrives sideways and suddenly opens up a whole new way of looking at the music. Hearing that it landed so strongly makes the time spent shaping it worthwhile.
      I appreciate the encouragement.
      Cheers.

      Delete
  5. A set of well presented songs from a new perspective. Keeps you guessing

    Thank you Butterboy

    Can I point out the true quote is 'VICE Versa' not Visa

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mike,
      Glad you enjoyed the set, that was exactly the aim, to present familiar songs from a slightly skewed angle and keep the listener guessing. It’s great to hear it worked for you.
      And thank you for the correction. You’re absolutely right, the true phrase is vice versa, not visa. A small slip on my part, and I appreciate you pointing it out.
      I must be one of the 10% of people who commonly make this mistake or must have been paying bills at the time...
      Cheers.

      Delete
  6. An amazing compilation and great idea. Hopefully there will be a 2nd part in the future.
    You definitely must have an enormous music archive (how is it possible to keep an overview....?)
    I have discoveres so much great stuff in your collections.
    Many thanks for your effort and the great work!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Void28,
      Thank you, that’s wonderful to hear. Knowing it sparked discoveries for you makes the effort worthwhile.
      As for the archive… it’s large, yes, but the trick is keeping everything organised by theme, mood, and era. Once it’s structured that way, the overview becomes manageable, and ideas for new compilations tend to reveal themselves naturally.
      I’m really glad my collections continue to bring you great music.
      Cheers.

      Delete