Previously posted April 3, 2020
VA - The Other Greatest Songwriters CD1 - CD4 (A Butterboy Compilation) (4 x CD's)
This set continues from the 100 greatest Songwriter (previously posted).
In 2015 Rolling Stone magazine published their 100 best songwriters of all time and included many of the modern greats such as John Lennon, Paul McCartney, Paul Simon, Willie Nelson, Dolly Parton, Kanye West and Joni Mitchell. There were some interesting less popular choices (thank goodness John Prine made it, although at an absurdly low position 94, and the late Merle Haggard) and who could argue with Van Morrison, Carole King or Randy Newman? But there were some major omissions. So here is an alternate list of the best 100 songwriters not included in the Rolling Stone 100.
When you see this list, you will shake your head saying "why wasn't that artist included the RS list"
Here are 100 OTHER Greatest Songwriters.
===========================================================
VA - The Other Greatest Songwriters CD1 - CD4 (A Butterboy Compilation) (4 x CD's)
This set continues from the 100 greatest Songwriter (previously posted).
In 2015 Rolling Stone magazine published their 100 best songwriters of all time and included many of the modern greats such as John Lennon, Paul McCartney, Paul Simon, Willie Nelson, Dolly Parton, Kanye West and Joni Mitchell. There were some interesting less popular choices (thank goodness John Prine made it, although at an absurdly low position 94, and the late Merle Haggard) and who could argue with Van Morrison, Carole King or Randy Newman? But there were some major omissions. So here is an alternate list of the best 100 songwriters not included in the Rolling Stone 100.
When you see this list, you will shake your head saying "why wasn't that artist included the RS list"
Here are 100 OTHER Greatest Songwriters.
===========================================================
or
===========================================================
Track lists
CD1
01 Queen Bohemian Rhapsody 5:50
02 Cole Porter I've Got You Under My Skin 3:48
03 Townes Van Zandt Pancho and Lefty 3:45
04 Ray Charles What Would I Do Without You 2:36
05 Damon Albarn For Tomorrow 4:21
06 Kate Bush The Man With the Child in His Eyes 2:41
07 Louis Jordan Is You is Or is You Ain't My Baby 3:17
08 Richard Thompson 1952 Vincent Black Lightning 5:07
09 John Hiatt Feels Like Rain 4:51
10 Ewan Maccoll & Peggy Seeger The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face 2:38
11 Irving Berlin What'll I Do 2:58
12 Stephen Sondheim Send in the Clowns 4:42
13 George Gershwin Rhapsody in Blue (Opening Section) 9:57
14 Joan Baez Diamonds & Rust 4:45
15 Cat Stevens Wild World 3:17
16 Phil Spector Be My Baby 2:41
17 Lefty Frizzell If You've Got the Money, I've Got the The Time 3:00
18 Paul Anka Lonely Boy 2:38
19 Shane McGowan The Song With No Name 4:05
20 Gordon Lightfoot Sundown 3:34
21 Gil Scott-Heron Pieces of a Man 4:54
22 Leadbelly Where Did You Sleep Last Night? 3:02
23 John Denver Back Home Again 4:45
24 Jelly Roll Morton Doctor Jazz 3:25
25 Otis Redding Try a Little Tenderness 3:18
CD2
26 Peter Gabriel Solsbury Hill 4:25
27 Guy Clark My Favorite Picture of You 3:32
28 Jarvis Cocker My Legendary Girlfriend 6:48
29 Loudon Wainwright III The Swimming Song 2:29
30 Frank Zappa Montana 6:38
31 Lyle Lovett If I Had a Boat 3:09
32 Nick Drake Place to Be 2:41
33 Tom Lehrer We'll All Go Together When We Go 5:23
34 2pac California Love 4:45
35 Bob Seger Turn the Page 5:07
36 John Lee Hooker Boom Boom 2:28
37 Neyo So Sick 3:26
38 Linda Perry What's Up 4:52
39 Steve Earle Guitar Town 2:35
40 Richard Shindell Arrowhead 4:09
41 Patty Griffin Moon Song (Live) 3:17
42 Beck Lost Cause 3:47
43 Noel Coward Mad Dogs and Englishmen 2:50
44 Joan Armatrading Love and Affection 4:27
45 Harold Arlen It's Only a Paper Moon 3:09
46 Rodney Crowell Many a Long & Lonesome Highway 4:16
47 Garry Frost What About Me 3:36
48 Amy Winehouse Rehab 3:35
49 Fred Neil The Dolphins 4:05
50 Bryan Ferry Do the Strand 4:00
CD3
51 John Cale Fear is a Man's Best Friend 3:53
52 Roy Orbison Penny Arcade 3:07
53 Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds The Mercy Seat (Acoustic Version) 3:45
54 Tracy Chapman Fast Car 4:57
55 Robert Plant & the Strange Sensation Mighty Rearranger 4:24
56 Nick Lowe I`m a Mess 3:12
57 Ryan Adams I See Monsters 3:57
58 Jeff Buckley Lover, You Should've Come Over 6:43
59 Laura Marling Sophia 4:51
60 Erykah Badu The Healer 3:59
61 Tim Hardin If I Were a Carpenter 2:42
62 Dr. John Right Place Wrong Time 2:54
63 Warren Zevon Desperados Under the Eaves 4:47
64 Ralph McTell Streets of London 4:08
65 Gram Parsons Return of the Grievous Angel 4:26
66 Rickie Lee Jones Living it Up 6:25
67 Chris Difford &Glenn Tilbrook Tempted 4:01
68 John Mellencamp Pink Houses 4:44
69 Bill Withers Lean on Me 4:19
70 Bobby Bland The Soul of a Man 3:03
71 John Martyn Solid Air 5:46
72 Cyndi Lauper Time After Time 4:01
73 Phil Ochs Outside of a Small Circle of Friends 3:43
74 Marc Bolan Bang a Gong - (Get it On) 4:27
75 Nanci Griffith I Don't Want to Talk About Love 4:07
CD4
76 Nina Simone Mississippi Goddam 4:57
77 Peter Case Dream About You 3:02
78 Lowell George 20 Million Things 2:43
79 Donovan The Hurdy Gurdy Man 3:18
80 Wc Handy St. Louis Blues 8:52
81 Ian Dury Sweet Gene Vincent 3:40
82 Ian Curtis Dead Souls 4:56
83 Luka Bloom Dreams in America 6:14
84 Don McLean Vincent 4:00
85 Christy Moore Lisdoonvarna 5:19
86 Coldplay The Scientist 5:09
87 Mark Knopfler The Ragpicker's Dream 4:20
88 Colin Meloy Rise to Me 4:59
89 Jeff Lynne Can't Get it Out of My Head 4:22
90 John Grant Gmf 5:13
91 Sandy Denny Solo 4:26
92 Vic Chesnut Supernatural 3:36
93 Elliott Smith Angeles 2:56
94 Pj Harvey Down By the Water 3:14
95 Jason Isbell Cover Me Up 4:52
96 Paul Weller You Do Something to Me 3:38
97 Ray Noble Love is the Sweetest Thing 3:23
98 Sia Taken for Granted 4:35
99 Annie Lennox Cold 4:24
100 Steve Winwood While You See a Chance 5:14
=============================================================
=============================================================
CD1
01 Queen Bohemian Rhapsody 5:50
02 Cole Porter I've Got You Under My Skin 3:48
03 Townes Van Zandt Pancho and Lefty 3:45
04 Ray Charles What Would I Do Without You 2:36
05 Damon Albarn For Tomorrow 4:21
06 Kate Bush The Man With the Child in His Eyes 2:41
07 Louis Jordan Is You is Or is You Ain't My Baby 3:17
08 Richard Thompson 1952 Vincent Black Lightning 5:07
09 John Hiatt Feels Like Rain 4:51
10 Ewan Maccoll & Peggy Seeger The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face 2:38
11 Irving Berlin What'll I Do 2:58
12 Stephen Sondheim Send in the Clowns 4:42
13 George Gershwin Rhapsody in Blue (Opening Section) 9:57
14 Joan Baez Diamonds & Rust 4:45
15 Cat Stevens Wild World 3:17
16 Phil Spector Be My Baby 2:41
17 Lefty Frizzell If You've Got the Money, I've Got the The Time 3:00
18 Paul Anka Lonely Boy 2:38
19 Shane McGowan The Song With No Name 4:05
20 Gordon Lightfoot Sundown 3:34
21 Gil Scott-Heron Pieces of a Man 4:54
22 Leadbelly Where Did You Sleep Last Night? 3:02
23 John Denver Back Home Again 4:45
24 Jelly Roll Morton Doctor Jazz 3:25
25 Otis Redding Try a Little Tenderness 3:18
CD2
26 Peter Gabriel Solsbury Hill 4:25
27 Guy Clark My Favorite Picture of You 3:32
28 Jarvis Cocker My Legendary Girlfriend 6:48
29 Loudon Wainwright III The Swimming Song 2:29
30 Frank Zappa Montana 6:38
31 Lyle Lovett If I Had a Boat 3:09
32 Nick Drake Place to Be 2:41
33 Tom Lehrer We'll All Go Together When We Go 5:23
34 2pac California Love 4:45
35 Bob Seger Turn the Page 5:07
36 John Lee Hooker Boom Boom 2:28
37 Neyo So Sick 3:26
38 Linda Perry What's Up 4:52
39 Steve Earle Guitar Town 2:35
40 Richard Shindell Arrowhead 4:09
41 Patty Griffin Moon Song (Live) 3:17
42 Beck Lost Cause 3:47
43 Noel Coward Mad Dogs and Englishmen 2:50
44 Joan Armatrading Love and Affection 4:27
45 Harold Arlen It's Only a Paper Moon 3:09
46 Rodney Crowell Many a Long & Lonesome Highway 4:16
47 Garry Frost What About Me 3:36
48 Amy Winehouse Rehab 3:35
49 Fred Neil The Dolphins 4:05
50 Bryan Ferry Do the Strand 4:00
CD3
51 John Cale Fear is a Man's Best Friend 3:53
52 Roy Orbison Penny Arcade 3:07
53 Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds The Mercy Seat (Acoustic Version) 3:45
54 Tracy Chapman Fast Car 4:57
55 Robert Plant & the Strange Sensation Mighty Rearranger 4:24
56 Nick Lowe I`m a Mess 3:12
57 Ryan Adams I See Monsters 3:57
58 Jeff Buckley Lover, You Should've Come Over 6:43
59 Laura Marling Sophia 4:51
60 Erykah Badu The Healer 3:59
61 Tim Hardin If I Were a Carpenter 2:42
62 Dr. John Right Place Wrong Time 2:54
63 Warren Zevon Desperados Under the Eaves 4:47
64 Ralph McTell Streets of London 4:08
65 Gram Parsons Return of the Grievous Angel 4:26
66 Rickie Lee Jones Living it Up 6:25
67 Chris Difford &Glenn Tilbrook Tempted 4:01
68 John Mellencamp Pink Houses 4:44
69 Bill Withers Lean on Me 4:19
70 Bobby Bland The Soul of a Man 3:03
71 John Martyn Solid Air 5:46
72 Cyndi Lauper Time After Time 4:01
73 Phil Ochs Outside of a Small Circle of Friends 3:43
74 Marc Bolan Bang a Gong - (Get it On) 4:27
75 Nanci Griffith I Don't Want to Talk About Love 4:07
CD4
76 Nina Simone Mississippi Goddam 4:57
77 Peter Case Dream About You 3:02
78 Lowell George 20 Million Things 2:43
79 Donovan The Hurdy Gurdy Man 3:18
80 Wc Handy St. Louis Blues 8:52
81 Ian Dury Sweet Gene Vincent 3:40
82 Ian Curtis Dead Souls 4:56
83 Luka Bloom Dreams in America 6:14
84 Don McLean Vincent 4:00
85 Christy Moore Lisdoonvarna 5:19
86 Coldplay The Scientist 5:09
87 Mark Knopfler The Ragpicker's Dream 4:20
88 Colin Meloy Rise to Me 4:59
89 Jeff Lynne Can't Get it Out of My Head 4:22
90 John Grant Gmf 5:13
91 Sandy Denny Solo 4:26
92 Vic Chesnut Supernatural 3:36
93 Elliott Smith Angeles 2:56
94 Pj Harvey Down By the Water 3:14
95 Jason Isbell Cover Me Up 4:52
96 Paul Weller You Do Something to Me 3:38
97 Ray Noble Love is the Sweetest Thing 3:23
98 Sia Taken for Granted 4:35
99 Annie Lennox Cold 4:24
100 Steve Winwood While You See a Chance 5:14
=============================================================
=============================================================
I hate "lists" because it usually shows up the bias of those that compile them. Sometimes I think there done just to be controversial.
ReplyDeleteI beg your pardon, Dr Robert, but your comment is neither fair nor clever. It is rude and impolite. BB can be proud of this "list", I myself will love to listen to this selection, and also look forward to many discoveries in it... Best (to BB only), TC
ReplyDeleteActually I was having a dig at Rolling Stone magazine who use these lists to generate controversy and therefore publicity - the best example being their 500 greatest albums list. To say that one album is best there ever was is ridiculous. The comment was in no way against this site which I think is one of the most stimulating and challenging on the web.
DeleteNow I understand the context of your statement. Case closed. Best, TC
DeleteGlad that's sorted. Thanks for working it out.
DeleteMy only hope is you both enjoy the two sets because at the end of the day it's the music that matters.
Cheers.
Lists do tend to tell us more about the compiler than the artists. But the fun is seeing where we overlap or disagree. Thanks for making time to do this. Keep on trucking BB.
ReplyDeleteHi lemonflag.
DeleteThere is no list that everyone would agree on but lists, for me, hold some truth as well. We can always think of material we prefer by a given singer/songwriter. But sometimes we rethink our position after relistening to a track on a compilation like this.
Cheers
Steve Winwood is in the original list - need a new #100👍
ReplyDeleteHi Brian F.
DeleteI must have gotten too excited or just tired.
Any Suggestion for a new #100?
Cheers.
May I suggest Al Stewart or Bruce Cockburn?
ReplyDeleteHi Peacenik,
DeleteBoth great choices.
Cheers.
Warren Zevon also in both. Re. 'replacements' - Al Stewart/Bruce Cockburn OK but how about evening up the hemispherical spread - Paul Kelly and Neil Murray from Oz? Love your work BB - forever thankful.
ReplyDeleteHi Magpie,
DeleteThanks.
Paul Kelly should be in there for sure, 100%. Neil Murray is great too. What about Neil Finn?
Cheers.
This is great, what you're doing BB, thx. My suggestion would be Paddy McAloon, if I may...
ReplyDeleteHi StoneRose.
DeletePaddy is terrific. Maybe we should have a reader's poll that does not include the singer/songwriters from the first two sets. mmmm... It would be interesting.
Cheers.
Have there already been mentions of those magnificent OZies Robert Forster & Grant McLennan (with the Go-Betweens, but also including their solo works) and/or the great Saints man Chris Bailey (especially "All Fools Day")? I think they would also be highly qualified for a future edition. Best, TC
ReplyDeleteI don't believe so, TC.
DeleteThe singer/songwriters we love needs to be a Readers Poll set.
Cheers.